In February 1897, the Indiana House of Representatives passed a bill built on the idea that the ratio of a circle’s circumference to its diameter is 3.2. Not a single member voted against it. It took a math professor who happened to be in the building to keep it from becoming law.
An Indiana doctor and a 2,000-year-old puzzle
The man behind it was Edward J. Goodwin, an Indiana physician turned amateur mathematician. In 1894, he became convinced he had solved one of the oldest problems in geometry: squaring the circle.
The challenge, first posed by the ancient Greeks, sounds simple. Take any circle and draw a square with exactly the same area, using only a compass and a straightedge.
Goodwin went further than solving it. He wanted his home state to own it. He brought a bill to state representative Taylor I. Record, titled “A Bill for an act introducing a new mathematical truth and offered as a contribution to education to be used only by the State of Indiana free of cost.” In other words, Indiana schools could use his discovery without paying him royalties, while everyone else presumably would.
Sent to the committee on canals
The bill bragged that Goodwin’s solutions had already been accepted by the American Mathematical Monthly. The truth was less glorious. They had appeared in a reader questions section of the journal in 1894, with no peer review, under the note “published by request of the author.”
Lawmakers were confused. The Speaker sent it to the Committee on Canals, also known as the Committee on Swamp Lands, where it could “find a deserved grave.”
It did not stay buried. The bill moved to the Committee on Education, which reported favorably, and on February 6, 1897, it passed the House without a dissenting vote.
The professor who walked in at the right moment
As the debate wrapped up, C. A. Waldo, a professor at Purdue University, arrived in Indianapolis on unrelated business: securing the yearly budget of the Indiana Academy of Science. An assemblyman handed him the bill and offered to introduce him to the genius who wrote it.
Waldo declined, explaining that he had already met as many crazy people as he cared to. Then he went to work on the senators.
In the Senate, a committee on temperance had also reported favorably, and the bill came close to passing. Opinion turned when one senator pointed out that the legislature had no power to define mathematical truth. The Indianapolis News described the scene on February 13: “The Senators made bad puns about it, ridiculed it and laughed over it. The fun lasted half an hour.”
Senator Hubbell then reminded his colleagues that the Senate was costing Indiana $250 a day. He moved to postpone the bill indefinitely, and the motion carried.
What the bill really said about pi
Here is the twist: despite its nickname, the “Indiana pi bill” never uses the word pi. Goodwin cared about the area of the circle, and pi was a side effect. One passage states that diameter and circumference are “as five-fourths to four”, which works out to pi equal to 3.2.
His core rule claimed that a circle has the same area as a square with the same perimeter. It doesn’t. The circle is always bigger. You may also have heard that Indiana nearly voted pi equal to 4. There is no evidence Goodwin ever meant that, even though his area rule points that way. The mathematician David Singmaster later counted seven different values of pi hidden in Goodwin’s work.
A problem that was already dead
The saddest part is the timing. Fifteen years earlier, in 1882, Ferdinand von Lindemann had proved that pi is transcendental. Put plainly, no compass-and-straightedge construction can ever produce it exactly, so the circle can never be squared that way. It joined the trisection of the angle on the list of famous impossible problems.
Even as an approximation, 3.2 was a step backward. Babylonian mathematicians used 3.125 around 2000 BC, and Archimedes pinned pi between about 3.141 and 3.143.
Goodwin was in famous company
He was far from the only one. The philosopher Thomas Hobbes convinced himself in old age that he had squared the circle, and John Wallis refuted him. Lewis Carroll once planned a book called “Plain Facts for Circle-Squarers.”
Meanwhile, real mathematicians found a smarter path: excellent approximations. In 1914, Srinivasa Ramanujan gave a geometric construction accurate to eight decimal places. No law required.
Today, “squaring the circle” simply means attempting the impossible. Indiana’s brush with it is a reminder that a unanimous vote can settle a lot of things. The value of pi was never one of them.

