Take any angle, grab an unmarked straightedge and a compass, and split it into three perfectly equal parts. The ancient Greeks set this puzzle, and in 1837 a young French mathematician proved it can never be done.
Pierre Wantzel showed that no amount of skill will ever trisect an arbitrary angle with those two tools alone. Yet mathematicians never stopped finding ways around the rules. Here are five of the cleverest.
Archimedes bent the rules with a spiral around 225 BC
The first loophole is older than the proof by about two thousand years. Around 225 BC, Archimedes described in his treatise On Spirals a way to trisect any angle using the curve that now carries his name, the Archimedean spiral.
The catch is simple: a spiral is neither a straight line nor a circle. Accept that one extra curve, and the impossible problem becomes solvable for every angle. Archimedes did not break geometry, he just brought a different tool to the table.
Two marks on a ruler change everything
The classical rules insist on an unmarked straightedge. Put a couple of marks on it, and you can trisect angles through what is called a neusis construction, where the marked ruler is slid and adjusted until its marks line up exactly where they need to be.
This is precisely where many would-be solvers trip up. Amateurs who announce a solution almost always break the original constraints without noticing, and quietly using a marked ruler is one of the classic ways it happens.
A piece of string wrapped around a cylinder
Thomas Hutcheson took a more hands-on route. In the journal Mathematics Teacher, he published a trisection method that relies on nothing more than a string wound around a cylinder.
It sounds like a party trick, but it is a smart sidestep. String and cylinders are simply not on the list of approved instruments, so the 1837 proof has nothing to say about them.
A strange instrument called the tomahawk
Then there is the tomahawk, a geometric instrument built from a semicircle and a few line segments. Positioned correctly against an angle, it divides that angle into three equal parts.
The twist is worthy of the problem itself. The tomahawk cannot be constructed in any position you like using only a straightedge and compass. In other words, the tool that solves the puzzle is itself out of reach of the classical rules.
A set square from 1932
The German mathematician Ludwig Bieberbach added his own solution in 1932. Published in the Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik, his construction relies on a specific right-angled set square, the triangular drafting tool.
Like every other entry on this list, it works precisely because it steps outside the original toolkit. Even folding paper does the job, as a famous origami discovery showed.
Why the classic version can never work
So why do a straightedge and compass fail where a piece of string succeeds? In algebraic terms, trisecting an angle is the same as constructing the solution of a cubic equation, one in which the unknown is multiplied by itself three times. Using the theory of field extensions, Wantzel showed that the two classical tools cannot produce such numbers in general.
He got there before Évariste Galois, whose related work was written in 1830 but only published in 1846, after his death. And some angles do slip through: a right angle splits neatly into three 30 degree pieces, and a 135 degree angle can be trisected too. A 60 degree angle, however, cannot, and that single counterexample is enough to sink any general method.
An impossible problem that refuses to die
None of this has stopped the hopeful. Mathematician Underwood Dudley devoted an entire book, The Trisectors, to the failed attempts submitted over the decades, and found the same misunderstandings of the rules surfacing again and again.
Perhaps that is the real lesson. An impossibility proof does not say a task can never be done, it says exactly which tools will never do it. Change the tools, and a two-thousand-year-old dead end turns into a playground.

