A popular story says Queen Victoria loved Alice in Wonderland so much that she demanded the author’s next book, and received a dense textbook on determinants. The author himself called it “utterly false.”
The story everyone repeats
The tale is irresistible. The Queen asks for more from the writer behind Alice, and what arrives is An Elementary Treatise on Determinants, a scholarly math volume about grids of numbers.
It turns up in biographies and trivia lists, and it fits the image of a whimsical author with a secret dry side.
What Dodgson said about it
Charles Dodgson, who wrote as Lewis Carroll, answered the rumor head on. He wrote that it was “utterly false in every particular: nothing even resembling it has occurred.”
Other writers found it unlikely too. T. B. Strong noted in a Times article that it would have been “clean contrary to all his practice” to link the author of Alice with the author of his mathematical works.
Dodgson kept his two names apart. The pen name dates from March 1856. He turned “Charles Lutwidge” into Latin, back into English, then reversed it, and the editor Edmund Yates picked “Lewis Carroll” from a list of four he had submitted.
The real mathematician behind the legend
The true story is less royal but more impressive. In 1854 Dodgson finished first on the list in the Final Honours School of Mathematics at Oxford. In 1855 he won the Christ Church Mathematical Lectureship, and he held it for 26 years.
That salary gave him financial security. Under his real name he published nearly a dozen books on geometry, linear algebra, logic and recreational math, including Euclid and his Modern Rivals in 1879.
He also wrote the first printed proof of the Rouché-Capelli theorem, a result about when a system of linear equations can be solved.
A shortcut for determinants
In 1866 he came up with a new way to compute a determinant, the single number that sums up a square grid of numbers (see our piece on why an empty matrix has a determinant of exactly 1).
His method, now called Dodgson condensation, works in layers. Take every 2 by 2 block of neighbors in the grid and compute its determinant, which gives a smaller grid. Repeat on that grid, divide by the matching middle entries from the earlier layer, and keep shrinking until one number is left.
That final number is the determinant of the original grid. The catch is that a zero in the interior forces a division by zero, so you must first swap rows around it.
The Gresham College lecture below, by Robin Wilson, walks through the mathematical world of Dodgson.
The puzzle that outlived him
The method earned a second life a century later. When Robbins and Rumsey investigated Dodgson condensation, it led them to the alternating sign matrix conjecture, which is now a proven theorem.
His logic work also aged well. In the posthumous second part of Symbolic Logic, he introduced the Method of Trees, the earliest modern use of a truth tree.
He never stopped tinkering, either. He invented the word ladder (CAT, COT, DOT, DOG), which first ran in Vanity Fair in 1879, and he proposed fairer elimination rules for tennis tournaments.
Why the myth stuck
Perhaps we want the tale to be true because it flatters both worlds: the playful storyteller and the rigorous mathematician in one body. The real answer is better. He did not need a queen to make his math matter, because his grids of numbers kept producing new questions long after he was gone.

