4.8/5 - (64 votes)

In January 1913, a 25-year-old accounting clerk in Madras mailed nine pages of formulas to a Cambridge professor, who first wondered whether he was being conned.

Two letters that came back without a word

Srinivasa Ramanujan was not the kind of man Cambridge expected to hear from. He had failed his college exams twice, lost a scholarship because he ignored every subject except math, and spent years so poor he was often on the brink of starvation.

By 1912 he had a job at the Madras Port Trust, as a Class III, Grade IV accounting clerk earning 30 rupees a month. He finished his office work quickly and spent the rest of his time on mathematics.

Friends helped him write to leading mathematicians in Britain. In London, M. J. M. Hill judged his papers “riddled with holes”. At Cambridge, the first two professors he tried, H. F. Baker and E. W. Hobson, simply returned his papers without comment.

Hardy’s first thought was fraud

On 16 January 1913, Ramanujan tried a third name: G. H. Hardy, whose book on orders of infinity he had studied. The letter came from a total unknown, and Hardy initially suspected a fraud.

It is easy to see why. Some of the formulas, in Hardy’s words, “seemed scarcely possible to believe”. One of them had already been found by a mathematician named G. Bauer back in 1859. Others were completely new to him.

Then he reached the last page, packed with results on continued fractions (fractions stacked inside fractions, endlessly). They “defeated me completely; I had never seen anything in the least like them before”, Hardy wrote. His conclusion became famous: they “must be true, because, if they were not true, no one would have the imagination to invent them”.

Hardy showed the pages to his colleague J. E. Littlewood. After talking it over, he called them “certainly the most remarkable” letters he had ever received.

See also  A question about growing money accidentally gave math one of its most famous numbers

Not a perfect letter, which made it more convincing

Hardy later went through 15 theorems from that first letter. The first 13 were correct and insightful. The 14th was wrong, but insightful. The 15th was correct, but misleading.

That mix hardly looks like a forgery. It looks like someone working entirely alone, rediscovering some things, getting a few wrong, and finding others nobody had ever seen.

Back in India, the surprises kept coming. A British professor in Madras once stormed into his class and asked his students, “Does Ramanujan know Polish?” Ramanujan had anticipated a Polish mathematician’s paper that had just arrived in that day’s mail.

No, he did not just guess the answers

Ramanujan’s notebooks list results almost without any proofs. That gave birth to a lasting myth: that he simply “saw” his formulas, through intuition or divine visions, and could not prove them.

The mathematician Bruce Berndt, who spent decades studying the notebooks, disagrees. Ramanujan could prove most of his results. He just did not write the proofs down.

The likely reason is painfully practical. Paper was very expensive, so he did most of his work on a slate, then copied only the final results onto paper. The one book that had trained him, G. S. Carr’s collection of 5,000 theorems, also stated results without proofs.

“Many people falsely promulgate mystical powers to Ramanujan’s mathematical thinking. It is not true”, Berndt said.

From clerk to Fellow of the Royal Society

Ramanujan sailed for England on 17 March 1914. In Cambridge he lived five minutes from Hardy’s room, and the atheist obsessed with rigor and the deeply religious man of intuition started working together.

See also  You never needed long division to test if a number divides by 7

In 1918, at 31, he became one of the youngest Fellows in the history of the Royal Society, and the first Indian Fellow of Trinity College. Hardy, who once ranked mathematicians on pure talent out of 100, reportedly gave himself 25, Littlewood 30, David Hilbert 80, and Ramanujan 100.

His health collapsed in England. He returned to India in 1919 and died in 1920, aged 32. Even then, his widow Janaki recalled, “he continued doing his mathematics filling sheet after sheet with numbers”.

A letter that is still being read

Ramanujan left nearly 3,900 results, and most have been proven correct. A forgotten fourth notebook of 87 pages resurfaced in 1976. As late as 2012, researchers found that throwaway remarks in his writings hid deep results in number theory, unsuspected for almost a century. You may also know him from a taxi number, 1729.

Like Sophie Germain writing to Gauss a century earlier, Ramanujan reached the top of mathematics through the mail. The difference is that two professors had already sent his pages back. It makes you wonder how many letters like his were never given a second look.