4.6/5 - (66 votes)

The number doctors use to size up your weight was not invented by a doctor. It came from a Belgian astronomer in the 1830s, and he never meant it to be used on individual patients.

His name was Adolphe Quetelet. He ran an observatory, studied shooting stars and the climate of Belgium, and somehow ended up giving medicine one of its most used numbers.

An astronomer who turned to people

Quetelet earned his doctorate in mathematics in 1819 and then spent years convincing officials and donors to fund an observatory in Brussels. It opened in 1828, and he directed it.

At the time, statistics was mostly an astronomer’s tool. Astronomers used it to deal with measurement errors scattered around an average value. Quetelet had a bolder idea: apply the same logic to society itself. He called the project “social physics”, and he wanted to find the statistical laws behind crime rates, marriage rates and suicide rates.

Many scientists of the era found this offensive, because it seemed to contradict free will.

The “average man” and his measurements

In his 1835 book on social physics, Quetelet introduced l’homme moyen, the “average man”. This figure was defined by the average values of many measured traits, and Quetelet noticed that those traits spread out in the familiar bell shape, the same pattern behind the normal distribution.

Here is where it gets strange. He did not treat the average as a boring midpoint. He treated it as an ideal, and saw deviations from it as being “more or less than ideal”. The average body, in his eyes, was a kind of beauty.

See also  One magazine answer triggered 10,000 angry letters, and it was right

The index that carried his name

Between 1830 and 1850, as part of this work, Quetelet devised the basis of what we now call the body mass index. Back then it was simply the Quetelet Index.

The idea is simple: divide a person’s weight by their height multiplied by itself. It gave a quick way to compare weight to height across a whole population.

The key point is its purpose. According to the historical record, Quetelet himself never intended the index as a medical assessment. It was a component of his study of the average man, and he thought of that average as a social ideal. The number was a tool for describing groups, not for diagnosing you.

How it got its modern name

The label we use today is much more recent. The term “body mass index” was coined in a paper published in July 1972 in the Journal of Chronic Diseases by Ancel Keys and colleagues. Keys argued that the index was “if not fully satisfactory, at least as good as any other relative weight index as an indicator of relative obesity”.

Interest in such an index grew as obesity became more common in prosperous Western societies. And Keys was explicit about a limit: he judged it appropriate for population studies and inappropriate for individual evaluation.

Why that distinction still matters

That warning is still cited today. Two people can have the same BMI and very different body composition and fat distribution. Lean male athletes, for example, often have a high muscle-to-fat ratio and a BMI that is misleadingly high relative to their body-fat percentage.

See also  Berkeley seemed to favor men in 1973, until the data was split

Even so, because it is so simple, the index became widely used for preliminary diagnoses. The usual adult bands, under 18.5, 18.5 to 24.9, 25 to 29.9, and 30 or more, are best understood as statistical categories rather than verdicts. Measures like waist circumference can be more useful for individuals.

A darker side of the average

Quetelet’s love of the average had a shadow. His idealization of the average man influenced Francis Galton, who later coined the term eugenics. His student Pierre François Verhulst, meanwhile, developed the logistic function as a model of population growth.

Quetelet also left a mark on Florence Nightingale, who met him at the 1860 International Statistical Congress in London and corresponded with him for years. It is a reminder that numbers describing crowds travel far, and are easy to misuse once they reach individuals.

One number, two very different jobs

The story of the BMI is really a story about scale. A statistic built to describe a whole population can be powerful, yet the same figure applied to one person can mislead. Next time a chart puts you in a category, remember that its inventor was looking at the crowd, not at you.