4.7/5 - (50 votes)

Long before anyone called her the Lady with the Lamp, the soldiers at Scutari had another name for Florence Nightingale: the lady with the hammer. And the woman behind both nicknames turned out to be one of the most persuasive statisticians of her century.

A nickname rewritten to sound more ladylike

Medicine the wounded badly needed was locked away in storage, so Nightingale broke in with a hammer. The troops gave her the nickname.

Russell, the reporter, saw it differently. He found the behaviour unladylike and came up with an alternative. A report in The Times described her gliding along the corridors at night “with a little lamp in her hand, making her solitary rounds.” Longfellow’s 1857 poem “Santa Filomena” did the rest.

The lamp stuck so well that Bank of England £10 notes printed between 1975 and 1994 showed her holding it in a field hospital. The softer image also buried the sharpest tool she ever used: numbers.

The real killer at Scutari was not the battlefield

Nightingale reached the military hospital at Scutari, across the Bosporus from Constantinople, in early November 1854 with 38 volunteer nurses. During that first winter, 4,077 British soldiers died there.

Most of them were not killed by the enemy. Ten times more soldiers died of typhus, typhoid, cholera and dysentery than of battle wounds. The hospital was overcrowded, the sewers were defective and the wards had no ventilation.

A Sanitary Commission arrived in March 1855, almost six months after she did. It flushed out the sewers, improved the airflow, and death rates fell sharply. She never claimed credit for that drop.

See also  Why a casino can lose on one spin but never lose over a year

The full picture came later. Back in Britain, gathering evidence for the Royal Commission on the Health of the Army, she came to believe that most of those men had been killed by poor living conditions, not by the war itself.

She did not invent the chart that made her famous

Nightingale had shown a gift for mathematics early, taught by her father at a time when, as historian I. Bernard Cohen put it, that was “most unusual of all for women of the time.”

Her most famous image is the polar area diagram, often called the Nightingale rose. Many people credit her with inventing it. She did not. André-Michel Guerry was already drawing what he called “circular curves” in 1829, and Léon Lalanne used polar diagrams too, long before her.

The pie chart itself goes back to William Playfair, who drew one in 1801. (Playfair had already published the first modern presentation charts in 1786, as we explained in our piece on the best chart ever drawn.)

A chart built for people who never read statistics

What Nightingale changed was the purpose. Her rose splits the year into 12 equal slices, one per month. Instead of changing the width of each slice, she changed how far it reached from the centre, so that the area of each wedge showed how many soldiers died that month.

Each wedge was then split by cause of death. One glance showed how disease dwarfed battle wounds. The finished shape looked a bit like a rooster’s crest, hence the nickname “coxcomb”, a word she originally used for the whole eye-catching book of charts rather than one diagram.

See also  She turned down a cup of tea and gave science one of its biggest ideas

Her target audience was precise: Members of Parliament and civil servants who were unlikely to read or understand a traditional statistical report. The charts appeared in 1858 in a report on the health of the British Army that was sent to Queen Victoria. Historian Hugh Small sums it up: “she may have been the first to use [pie charts] for persuading people of the need for change.”

In 1859, she became the first female member of the Royal Statistical Society.

The numbers kept saving lives long after the war

From 1857 onwards, Nightingale was often bedridden. She kept working from home anyway. She turned her statistics on the British Army in India, showing that bad drainage, dirty water, overcrowding and poor ventilation were behind its high death rate.

By 1873, after ten years of sanitary reform, she reported that soldier deaths in India had fallen from 69 to 18 per 1,000.

She then lobbied for the Public Health Acts of 1874 and 1875, which forced property owners to connect homes to mains drainage. Historians now believe drainage and local enforcement played a crucial role in adding 20 years to average life expectancy in Britain between 1871 and the mid-1930s.

She also counted Ada Lovelace among her friends, the woman behind what is often called the first computer program.

The lamp makes a lovely statue. But it was a carefully drawn chart, aimed at people who hated reading numbers, that may have saved the most lives.