4.8/5 - (55 votes)

In 1512, during the sack of Brescia, a French soldier slashed a young boy across the jaw and palate with a sabre and left him for dead. The boy survived, grew up to crack one of the hardest problems in Renaissance mathematics, and then watched another man put it in print first.

His name was Niccolò Tartaglia. The equation he tamed was the cubic, and the story of who really owns its solution still trips up math textbooks today.

The boy everyone called the stammerer

The sabre wound left Tartaglia with a lasting speech impediment. That is where his nickname comes from: “Tartaglia” means “the stammerer” in Italian. As an adult, he grew a beard to hide the scars.

His father Michele, a dispatch rider, was murdered by robbers in 1506. At around fourteen, the boy had to stop his lessons when he could no longer pay his teacher. They had reached the letter “k”.

From then on, he wrote, he carried on “by myself”. He moved to Verona around 1517, then to Venice in 1534, teaching practical math in abacus schools and selling answers to gunners and architects.

A problem that beat the greatest minds for centuries

A cubic equation is one where the unknown number gets multiplied by itself three times, the way you would calculate the volume of a cube. People had wrestled with them since antiquity.

Yet nobody had a general recipe. In the 11th century, the Persian scholar Omar Khayyam solved them with clever geometry but admitted defeat on the algebra: “We have tried to express these roots by algebra but have failed.”

Then an Italian mathematician, Scipione del Ferro (1465 to 1526) found a method for one family of cubics: a cube plus some multiple of the unknown, equal to a given number. He told almost no one. Only shortly before his death did he pass the secret to his student, Antonio Fior.

See also  She staged a fake marriage just to be allowed to study math

Thirty problems, thirty days

In 1535, Tartaglia claimed he could solve two cubic problems sent to him by a man named Zuanne da Coi. Fior, armed with his master’s secret, challenged him to a contest.

The rules were simple. Each side posed problems to the other, and whoever solved more within 30 days took all the money. Fior sent thirty questions, every one of them the exact type del Ferro’s method could crack.

He had bet on the wrong man. Tartaglia had worked out a method of his own, and he won. The self-taught stammerer had beaten the heir to a secret formula at his own game.

A promise, a poem and a loophole

News of the victory reached Gerolamo Cardano, a famous scholar. In 1539, he persuaded Tartaglia to reveal the method, swearing never to publish it. Tartaglia finally handed it over, written in verse.

Cardano later learned that del Ferro had found the same solution earlier, in work that had never been published. In 1545, he printed the method in his book Ars Magna, the same book where square roots of negative numbers made their awkward first appearance in print.

His justification was a neat loophole. He argued he was publishing del Ferro’s method, not Tartaglia’s, so his promise did not apply. He even gave Tartaglia six years to publish his own results first, with credit for an independent solution.

Tartaglia, furious, challenged Cardano, who declined. Cardano’s student Lodovico Ferrari took up the fight. Ferrari had started out as Cardano’s servant, and he was mainly responsible for solving the even harder fourth-degree equations that Cardano also published. He did better than Tartaglia, who lost both prestige and income.

See also  An empty matrix has a determinant of exactly 1, and that is no accident

So whose formula is it, really

School textbooks still call it “Cardano’s formula”. Historians are more generous: they credit both men and often speak of the Cardano-Tartaglia formula.

Popular retellings claim Tartaglia spent the rest of his life trying to ruin Cardano. Those accounts appear to be fabricated.

Tartaglia’s real legacy was far bigger than one feud. In 1537, his book Nova Scientia applied math to cannon fire and found that a projectile flies farthest at a 45 degree angle. In 1543, he published the first translation of Euclid’s Elements into a modern European language. He even knew Pascal’s famous triangle of numbers a century before Pascal.

A formula with three fathers

Tartaglia died in Venice on 13 December 1557. His roughly 1,500-page treatise on numbers and measures, written in Venetian dialect, was still being printed after his death.

The solution to the cubic now carries one name, but it took three men to bring it into the world: one who hid it, one who rediscovered it alone, and one who dared to print it. It is a reminder that in mathematics, as anywhere else, the name on a discovery rarely tells the whole story.