4.8/5 - (34 votes)

In 1924, two Polish mathematicians proved that a solid ball can be cut into a handful of pieces and put back together as two balls, each exactly the size of the original.

No stretching, no bending, no extra material. It sounds like a magic trick, yet it is an accepted theorem, known as the Banach–Tarski paradox.

Five pieces, two identical balls

The statement is disarmingly simple. Split a ball into a finite number of pieces that do not overlap. Move and turn them, without changing their shape. You end up with two perfect copies of the original.

How many pieces does it take? The mathematician Raphael M. Robinson settled it: five pieces are enough, and fewer than five will never work.

A stronger version says that any two “reasonable” solid objects can be turned into each other this way. Mathematicians sum it up with a famous image: a pea can be chopped up and reassembled into the Sun.

The catch is hiding in the pieces

Your intuition screams that this is impossible, because moving and rotating things should never change their volume. That intuition is not silly. It is actually built into the formal definition of volume.

The trick is that the pieces are not solids at all. They are infinite scatterings of points, so tangled that it is impossible to give them a volume. Mathematicians call them non-measurable sets. Since they have no volume to begin with, there is no total volume to “conserve” along the way.

That is why nobody will ever double a gold bar this way: the pieces cannot be cut in any practical sense. Mathematicians call it a veridical paradox. It shocks common sense, but it is neither false nor self-contradictory.

See also  A US state almost made pi 3.2, until a professor walked in

The controversial rule that makes it work

Unlike most theorems in geometry, this one depends critically on which basic rules you accept for building sets. The key ingredient is the axiom of choice, which lets mathematicians assume they can pick one element from each of an infinite number of collections, even when no recipe exists for making those picks.

Building the strange pieces of the paradox requires an uncountable number of such choices. Without it, the proof collapses. In 1964, Paul Cohen showed that this axiom can be neither proved nor disproved from the other standard rules of set theory.

Banach and Tarski knew exactly what they were poking at. In their 1924 paper, they wrote: “The role this axiom plays in our reasoning seems to us to deserve attention.” Their point: the same axiom also proves perfectly intuitive results, so rejecting it because of this paradox would undermine those too.

A conversation overheard in a park

The story behind the theorem starts years earlier, in 1916, in Kraków’s Planty park. The mathematician Hugo Steinhaus was strolling through the gardens when he overheard the words “Lebesgue integral,” a fairly new idea in mathematics at the time.

Intrigued, he walked over. There he met Stefan Banach, a self-taught young mathematician. Steinhaus gave him a few problems that had resisted his own efforts, and Banach solved them within a week. He later received a doctorate without ever graduating from a university.

The irony is delicious. Lebesgue’s work underpins the modern notion of volume, the very notion the paradox would later show cannot cover every possible piece of space. In 2016, a bench honoring Banach and Otto Nikodym was unveiled in the same park.

See also  5 facts about tiling patterns that took mathematicians centuries to prove

His co-author had his own twist of identity. Alfred Tarski was born Alfred Teitelbaum, enrolled at the University of Warsaw to study biology, and changed his surname in 1923, just a year before the famous paper.

Why it only works in three dimensions

The paradox fails on a line and on a flat plane. In two dimensions, an area can be defined for every bounded shape, so a disc can never become two identical discs.

The difference comes from rotations. In three dimensions, they can be combined in a much richer way, and the proof exploits exactly that. Studying this led John von Neumann to a fruitful new line of research on groups.

The flat world still has its own surprise. In 1925, Tarski asked whether a disc could be cut into pieces and rearranged into a square of the same area. Miklós Laczkovich proved in 1990 that it can, using roughly 1050 pieces. With a pair of ordinary scissors, though, it is impossible, a distant cousin of the ancient problem of squaring the circle.

What a pea and the Sun say about infinity

Banach–Tarski does not break physics. It reveals something about infinity: once shapes can be made of infinitely many scattered points, an idea as solid as volume stops applying everywhere. A century later, the pea and the Sun remain a striking reminder that mathematics follows its rules, not our intuitions.