4.5/5 - (34 votes)

On 8 September 1854, the handle of a water pump in Soho, London, was removed, and the story goes that a deadly cholera outbreak stopped on the spot. The doctor who asked for it wrote that it was impossible to tell.

His name was John Snow. The pump made him famous, but his real proof came from somewhere else: a comparison of 300,000 Londoners.

Three days, 127 deaths

The outbreak began on 31 August 1854 around Broad Street, near Golden Square. In three days, 127 people on or near the street died. Within a week, three quarters of the residents had fled.

By the end, 420 people were dead. Snow later called it “the most terrible outbreak of cholera which ever occurred in this kingdom.”

Many victims were carried to the Middlesex Hospital, where Florence Nightingale, weeks before leaving for the Crimea, worked day and night receiving them.

Almost everyone in charge blamed the air. The dominant miasma theory blamed foul vapors from rotting matter. London’s chief medical officer, John Simon, called Snow’s idea that it spread through water “peculiar.”

The legend of the pump handle

Snow went door to door with a local curate, the Reverend Henry Whitehead. What he found was striking: “nearly all the deaths had taken place within a short distance of the pump.”

Only ten deaths happened in houses clearly closer to another pump. Five of those families said they always fetched water from Broad Street anyway, because they preferred its water. Three of the victims were children who went to school near it.

See also  A 99 percent accurate medical test can still be wrong most of the time

His microscope found nothing conclusive in the water. But the pattern was enough. On the evening of 7 September, he presented it to the parish authorities, and the handle came off the next day.

That is where the legend ends. Snow’s own account does not. He noted that cases had already dropped sharply before the pump was disabled, partly because so many people had fled. In his words, it was “impossible to decide whether the well still contained the cholera poison in an active state.”

The brewery where nobody got sick

Snow then drew his famous map, a dot for every case. He also, in effect, split the neighborhood into zones, each one containing every address closer to a given pump than to any other. Mathematicians call this a Voronoi diagram. The zone around Broad Street had by far the most cases.

One detail stood out. No worker at the Broad Street brewery caught cholera. They received a daily beer allowance and never drank from the well, and brewing involves boiling.

The cause emerged later: the well sat just 3 feet from a leaking cesspit, where the diapers of a baby who had caught cholera elsewhere had been washed.

The real proof came from 300,000 people

Snow did not want to rest his case on Broad Street at all. A scattered, fleeing population was a shaky basis for any conclusion.

His stronger evidence came from two water companies that both drew from the Thames. Southwark and Vauxhall took its water from sections polluted by sewage. Lambeth took its supply farther upriver, where the water was cleaner.

See also  Four datasets share the same averages and correlation, yet look nothing alike

Both companies served rich and poor alike, and in many streets a single house had a different supplier from the houses on either side. Snow saw that some 300,000 people had been “divided into two groups without their choice, and, in most cases, without their knowledge.”

He then compared death rates. Homes served by Southwark and Vauxhall had a cholera rate 14 times higher. As Snow put it, no experiment could have been devised to test the water more thoroughly. Today this is called a natural experiment. Unlike a cluster noticed after the fact (the classic Texas sharpshooter trap), the two groups were set by the pipes before anyone counted a single death.

The pump, meanwhile, “hardly made a dent in the citywide cholera epidemic, which went on to claim nearly 3,000 lives.”

London put the handle back

Once the crisis passed, officials reattached the handle and rejected Snow’s theory. The Board of Health blamed the 1854 epidemic on miasma. Accepting that people were drinking each other’s waste was too unpleasant to contemplate.

Snow died of a stroke in June 1858, aged 45. Only in 1866 did William Farr, the census official who had been one of his chief opponents, investigate another outbreak and order that unboiled water must not be drunk.

In 2013, The Lancet even published a correction to its brief 1858 obituary, acknowledging his “visionary work in deducing the mode of transmission of epidemic cholera.”

Snow is now seen as a founder of epidemiology, not for one handle, but for comparing two groups that differed in only one way. Nearly every modern health study still rests on that same simple idea.

See also  No, Benford's law wasn't first discovered by Frank Benford