4.4/5 - (45 votes)

In 1915, one of the sharpest minds in Germany arrived at the University of Göttingen to teach, and for years the lecture listings carried a man’s name instead of hers.

A university that did not want her

Emmy Noether was born in Erlangen, Bavaria, in 1882, the daughter of the mathematician Max Noether. In 1900 she passed the exam to teach French and English in girls’ schools, with the grade “very good”. She chose mathematics instead.

That was a bold move. Two years earlier, the Academic Senate of the University of Erlangen had declared that mixed-sex education would “overthrow all academic order”. Noether was one of just two women among 986 students, and she could only audit classes, with permission from each professor.

She earned her doctorate in 1907, summa cum laude. Her thesis ended with a list of more than 300 invariants, all worked out by hand. She later called it “crap”, and never went back to that style of math.

Then came seven years of teaching at Erlangen’s Mathematical Institute without pay. Her two doctoral students there were officially supervised by him, not by her.

Not a bathhouse

In early 1915, David Hilbert and Felix Klein invited her to Göttingen. Historians and philologists on the faculty blocked the move, insisting that women should not teach at that level.

One faculty member asked: “What will our soldiers think when they return to the university and find that they are required to learn at the feet of a woman?” Hilbert was furious. His exact words were never recorded, but he is often said to have replied that the university was not a bathhouse.

See also  He carved a formula into a bridge, and spacecraft still rely on it

So Noether taught anyway, with no official position, no salary, and lectures often advertised under Hilbert’s name, with her providing “assistance”. According to her friend Pavel Alexandrov, the opposition was not only about her gender, but also about her left-wing politics and her Jewish ancestry.

The theorem physicists still lean on

Hilbert and Klein had a reason for wanting her: Einstein’s brand new theory of gravity, general relativity, seemed to break the law of conservation of energy. Noether solved the puzzle in a 1918 paper, and gave physics one of its most powerful tools along the way.

Her theorem says, in plain words, that every smooth symmetry in the laws of nature comes with something that never changes. If the laws work the same no matter which way you face, spin is conserved. Even a jagged asteroid tumbling through space keeps its spin, because it is the laws that are symmetric, not the rock. If an experiment works the same anywhere and at any time, momentum and energy are conserved.

Einstein wrote to Hilbert: “The old guard at Göttingen should take some lessons from Miss Noether! She seems to know her stuff.” Physicists Leon Lederman and Christopher Hill later ranked her result as possibly on a par with the Pythagorean theorem.

Yet she did not present it herself. On 26 July 1918, Felix Klein read the paper to Göttingen’s Royal Society of Sciences, because Noether was not a member.

Credit she kept giving away

After the German Revolution of 1918 to 1919 shifted attitudes, Göttingen finally let her qualify as a lecturer. That fall, the first courses listed under her own name appeared. She was still unpaid, and only got a small salary in 1923.

See also  A Berlin job offer reached this genius 2 days after he died at 26

By then she had turned to pure algebra. Her 1921 paper on ideals was called “revolutionary”, and objects that follow her rules are still called Noetherian. Many see it as the true founding moment of abstract algebra, as we explained in our story on how algebra was rebuilt.

She often let others, including her own students, take credit for her ideas, so much of her work appeared in papers without her name. When the building was closed for a holiday, she led her class through the woods and lectured in a coffee house.

Expelled, then remembered

In April 1933 under the new Nazi regime, a letter from the Prussian ministry withdrew her right to teach. When one of her students showed up in a Nazi SA uniform, she showed no sign of agitation, and reportedly laughed about it later.

She moved to Bryn Mawr College in the United States and lectured at Princeton’s Institute for Advanced Study, while describing Princeton University was “the men’s university, where nothing female is admitted”. She died in April 1935, at 53, after surgery.

Einstein wrote to The New York Times that she was “the most significant creative mathematical genius thus far produced since the higher education of women began”. Like Sophie Germain a century earlier, she did world-class math from the margins. Today an asteroid bears her name, and as historian Jeremy Gray put it, “Mathematicians simply do ring theory her way.”