4.4/5 - (48 votes)

From 1936 to 2000, a single NFL game predicted the outcome of every U.S. presidential election, and it had nothing to do with politics.

Statisticians have a name for this trap: cum hoc ergo propter hoc, assuming that because two things happen together, one must be causing the other. History is full of correlations that looked airtight for years, until someone found the real explanation hiding underneath.

The football game that called elections for 64 years

Between 1936 and 2000, whenever Washington’s NFL team won its final home game before the election, the incumbent party kept the White House. Whenever the team lost, the challenger’s party won instead. The pattern held so consistently that it earned its own nickname, the Redskins Rule.

Then in 2004, the streak simply broke. The rule was never a rule at all, just a run of coincidences that lasted an improbably long time before the odds finally caught up with it.

Windmills that seem to create their own wind

Watch a windmill closely and a strange thought can creep in. The faster the blades spin, the harder the wind seems to blow, which makes it tempting to conclude that the windmill is generating the wind itself.

The real relationship runs the other way entirely. Wind exists completely independently of the windmill, and the blades simply spin faster because more wind is already blowing, not the reverse.

Ice cream sales and drowning deaths rise together

Every summer, ice cream sales climb, and so does the number of drowning deaths. Read as a straight line of cause and effect, that would suggest dessert is dangerous.

See also  A 1960 puzzle built on 2, 4, 6 exposed a flaw in how we all think

The real driver is temperature. Hot weather sends more people out to buy ice cream and, separately, more people into swimming pools and open water, where drownings are naturally more likely to happen.

Lice, fever, and a very backwards conclusion

In medieval Europe, many people genuinely believed that carrying lice was a sign of good health, since sick people usually had noticeably fewer of them.

The lice were never protecting anyone. A fever raises body temperature, and lice cannot tolerate the extra heat, so they abandon a sick person’s body long before recovery even begins. Good health did not chase the lice away, the fever did.

A medical study that blamed the wrong culprit

In 1999, a study published in the journal Nature suggested that sleeping with a light on during childhood could cause myopia later in life. It made headlines and worried plenty of parents.

Follow-up research from Ohio State University in 2000 found the actual cause. Parents who are already myopic tend to leave a light on for their own convenience, and they are also the ones most likely to pass myopia on to their children through genetics. The light itself was never the problem.

Why the correlation is still worth noticing

None of this makes correlation useless. It is often the first clue that leads researchers toward a real cause, as long as it gets treated as a starting point and never as a conclusion on its own.

The next time two trends move in perfect sync, from social media use to stock prices, the honest question is not what proves what. It is what third factor might be quietly moving both of them at once.

See also  A 1936 poll heard from 2.4 million voters and still got it wrong