4.4/5 - (37 votes)

Some of his rivals called him “Beta,” Greek for Number 2, because he was never the top expert in any single field. Yet around 240 BC, this librarian measured the size of the entire Earth using little more than a stick, a well, and two shadows.

The scholar who finished second at everything

Eratosthenes was born around 276 BC in Cyrene, in modern Libya. He spent about twenty years studying in Athens before the king of Egypt summoned him to Alexandria to run the Library there and tutor the royal heir.

His fans nicknamed him Pentathlos, after the athletes who competed in five events. The critics twisted that same word: a pentathlete can also be someone who comes second in every event. The geographer Strabo summed up the problem neatly, calling him “a mathematician among geographers and a geographer among mathematicians.”

A well that cast no shadow

The clue came from a report about the town of Syene, today’s Aswan. At noon on the summer solstice, rods there cast no shadow at all, and sunlight shone straight down into a well.

In Alexandria, on the same day and at the same hour, a vertical rod did cast a shadow. Eratosthenes measured its angle at about 7.2 degrees, which is one fiftieth of a full circle.

Turning a shadow into a planet

Here is the leap. Sunlight reaches us as nearly parallel rays. If the ground were flat, both rods would cast identical shadows. Because the two shadows differed, the surface between the two cities had to be curved, and the angle of the difference revealed how much of the circle separated them.

See also  She called herself a slow mathematician, then won the Fields Medal

Professional distance walkers, called bematists, put the trip between the two cities at about 5,000 stadia. If that distance is one fiftieth of the circle, the full circle is 50 times longer: roughly 250,000 stadia. No complicated formula, just proportion.

One modern scholar converts that figure to about 40,338 kilometers. The real equatorial circumference is about 40,075 kilometers, so the ancient answer lands within roughly 1 percent.

Two mistakes that cancelled out

The result is even stranger once you check the assumptions. Eratosthenes believed Syene sat exactly on the Tropic of Cancer. It actually lies about 1 degree north of it. He also assumed Syene was due south of Alexandria, when it is really about 3 degrees east.

His method was sound, but two wrong assumptions happened to cancel each other out. It is a good reminder that a brilliant idea and a lucky break often travel together.

More than one big idea

The Earth was only the beginning. Eratosthenes also estimated the tilt of the Earth’s axis, which turned out remarkably accurate. In a three-volume work called Geography, he coined the words “geography” and “geographer,” divided the world into five climate zones, and drew a grid of parallels and meridians linking more than 400 cities.

He kept up with the best minds of his day. Archimedes addressed his famous Method of Mechanical Theorems to him as a letter, and Eratosthenes built a mechanical device to approximate the solution to doubling the cube, even sending a bronze model to the king. He also gave the prime-number sieve its name, although some scholars say the method was already known before him.

See also  A lost geometry manuscript resurfaced by pure chance in 1845

What second place really looks like

Most of his books are lost, including the one where he described the Earth measurement itself. We know the method mainly through a simplified account written by a later author named Cleomedes.

The nickname “Number 2” has not aged well. Today, he is remembered as the person who showed that a planet could be measured from a single shadow, and that the right question can matter more than any instrument.